It’s really difficult for me to write these days. I’ve just come back from a 3 day wedding - a wedding filled with firsts: the first Indian wedding (this was a North Indian wedding), the first family wedding I’ve attended (my cousin), and the first event where I have had to be around family, fully decked out in North Indian clothes and seen as an adult.
A lot of life is about performance, I’ve come to realize. It’s all about those little details that keep family from getting caught in arguments - what I refer to as “family politics” - a fake laugh, keeping your mouth shut when your elders tell you that you’ve gained weight, learning not to correct “art college” from “liberal arts college” when they attempt to belittle your choice in humanities. At a certain point, whether I intend to or not, I find my eyes move slightly down, my walk becomes a little slower and my voice is heard considerably less when I’m at family events (hereby referred to as “functions”). These things all come down to the gender roles that have been assigned to me through a variety of things - little comments that were made to me as a child by extended family, the media. And the particularities of these gender roles are dictated by my family’s culture.
I have a long history with battling culture. I was sitting at the henna-ceremony, looking around at the one of 40 women that had attended the event who was around my age. The first was 23. And married. Her hair was perfectly straight and her outfit was perfectly tailored and her husband was an attractive and wealthy South Asian man. She looked like an Indian Barbie doll. She looked domesticated and manicured and feminine - and to be honest, it doesn’t matter whether she is reading Sister Outsider under her covers with a flashlight while her husband is asleep or not. What matters is her performance - her ability to fit a model that is dictated by a culture that I cannot relate to.
My claim is this: I don’t know if I ever will feel connected to my identity as an Indian-American because of culture. Culture is not the thing that dictates my struggle for social justice. The reality is, the aspects of “Indianness” that make me feel like an Indian-American is the solidarity I share with other Indian-Americans regarding racism, sexism and homophobia in the community. It is often shared experience my family has with other South Asian families that immigrate to the United States. It is the brown color of my skin that I have grown to love that helps me to identify as Indian-American. It is my parents. My grandparents. My aunt.
There is more to say, but it will have to wait.
Cross-posted at Feministe

5 comments
Comments feed for this article
June 26, 2007 at 9:49 pm
utopia
Brown Woman I love the content of your posts and love the way you put across such valid points in a thought provoking manner. Here in India I think we have taken our Indian identity for granted. Some ways women over here are so stifled and again we do have a certain indpendence which comes from being around people who are alike. I can so relate to your thoughts when you saw your pretty Indian cousin. I am astonished too when so many of my friends choose holy matrimony over a life lived based on one’s own choices.
June 27, 2007 at 8:56 pm
shazmoo
Is it really that hard to “be yourself” even within a culture that expects you not to be? I only ask coming from a similar background and sharing similar experiences yet never letting their expectations overcome who I am. Never willing to put that on hold to placate their desires.
Maybe I’m just idealistic.
June 27, 2007 at 9:15 pm
-obw
Shazmoo –
Usually I don’t comment on comments, simply because I never get around to it and I never know if the person I’m responding to will read the response - but anyway. I just read your comment and wanted to say that I understand what you’re saying. And for the most part, when it comes right down to it, my family or culture has not limited who I am. It doesn’t stop me from pursuing a major in humanities, it doesn’t keep me from being loud and radical and crazy. It doesn’t keep me from being a brown woman who has found wonderful and equally loud brown woman who face similar challenges in mainstream/normalized North Indian culture. Part of the ease in doing this is that my mother has paved this way for me in her generation and has always encouraged me to “be myself”. All of this said - when it comes to family functions, there are limits. These limits are made in order to respect the people around me, and to keep my mother from getting any more shit about parenting than she probably already has. I think it comes to choosing my battles.
July 4, 2007 at 3:27 pm
mum
love you and am very proud of who you are and have grown into one fine brown woman
July 11, 2007 at 11:47 pm
shazmoo
I entirely agree with your comment and wish you all the best.